#StackBounty: #mongodb #database-design #nosql #mongoengine MongoDB : How to design schema based on application access patterns?

Bounty: 100

As someone that comes from DynamoDB, modeling a MongoDB schema to really fit deeply into my application is kinda confusing, specially since it has the concept of references and from what I read is not recommended to keep duplicated data to accomodate your queries.

Take the following example (modeled in mongoengine, but shouldn’t matter) :

    #User
    class User(Document):
        email = EmailFieldprimary_key=True)
        pswd_hash = StringField()
        #This also makes it easier to find the Projects the user has a Role
        roles = ListField(ReferenceField('Role')

    #Project
    class Project(Document):
        name = StringField()
        #This is probably unnecessary as the Role id is already the project id
        roles = ListField(ReferenceField('Role'))

    #Roles in project
    class Role(Document):
        project = ReferenceField('Project', primary_key=True)
        #List of permissions
        permissions = ListField(StringField())
        users = ListField(ReferenceField('User')

There are Projects and Users.

Each Project can have many Roles in it.

Each User can have one Role in a Project.


So, it’s a Many-Many between Users and Projects

A Many-One between Users and Roles

A Many-One between Roles and Projects


The problem is when I try to accomodate the schema to the access, because on every page refresh on the application, I need :

  1. Project (the id is in the url)
  2. User (email is in session)
  3. User permissions in that project (server-side security checks)

So, considering this is the most common query, how should I model my schema to accomodate it?

Or is the way I’m doing at the moment okay already?


Get this bounty!!!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.